How Much Money Has Trump Saved Taxpayers, Really?

Are you curious about the real financial impact of Trump’s policies on taxpayers? At savewhere.net, we explore this question, delving into the details of government efficiency and the potential consequences of budget cuts. Let’s examine the data and separate fact from fiction, offering you clear insights into how your money is being managed and how you can achieve better financial stability.

1. What Was Trump’s Stated Goal for Taxpayer Savings?

President Donald Trump and his administration aimed to cut costs and shrink the federal government, asserting it was bloated, inefficient, and a bastion of political opposition. This goal sought to reduce government spending and increase efficiency across various federal agencies.

Trump’s administration argued that reducing the size of government would lead to significant savings for taxpayers. By cutting what they viewed as unnecessary programs and personnel, they believed they could make the government more efficient and fiscally responsible. This initiative resonated with many voters who felt the government was too large and wasteful. A key part of this strategy was targeting what they referred to as the “deep state,” aiming to remove individuals they perceived as obstructing their policies. This involved scrutinizing and, in some cases, removing civil servants deemed resistant to the administration’s agenda. The approach included tactics such as targeting probationary workers in federal agencies, who are easier to terminate due to fewer civil service protections. This method allowed for quicker staff reductions and a more streamlined implementation of the administration’s cost-cutting measures. Overall, the stated goal was to create a leaner, more efficient government that would ultimately save taxpayers money by reducing waste and improving fiscal management. However, the actual impact and effectiveness of these measures have been subjects of debate and scrutiny.

2. How Did the Trump Administration Attempt to Reduce Government Spending?

The Trump administration used several tactics to reduce government spending, including targeting probationary employees and proposing significant budget cuts across various agencies. These actions aimed to shrink the size of the federal government and decrease its overall financial burden.

One key strategy was to target probationary employees, who are easier to fire due to having fewer civil service protections. This allowed the administration to quickly reduce staff numbers, particularly in agencies like the IRS, which had recently increased hiring. For instance, in late February, the Trump administration began firing over 6,000 IRS employees, many of whom were still in their probationary period. This approach was seen as a swift way to cut costs, though it also resulted in the loss of skilled and experienced personnel. The administration also drafted plans to cut the entire federal workforce in half, according to reports. Such drastic measures were intended to significantly reduce the financial strain on the government. This involved identifying areas where they believed resources were being wasted or mismanaged. Furthermore, the administration sought to demoralize remaining workers, aiming to create an environment where employees would be less inclined to resist changes. As Russell Vought, director of the Trump White House’s Office of Management and Budget, stated, the goal was to make bureaucrats “traumatically affected” and less motivated to come to work. Overall, the Trump administration employed a multifaceted approach to reduce government spending, using both direct cuts and strategic personnel management to achieve its fiscal objectives.

3. What Happened to IRS Employees During Trump’s Tenure?

During the Trump administration, the IRS experienced significant staff reductions, including the firing of over 6,000 employees, many of whom were in their probationary period. These cuts were part of a broader effort to reduce the size and cost of the federal government.

These specialists possessed technical expertise in areas such as chemical and nuclear engineering, allowing them to audit complex tax returns filed by large corporations and wealthy individuals. According to current and former LB&I employees, the taxpayers they audited included pharmaceutical companies, oil and gas companies, construction firms, and major technology corporations, as well as more obscure private corporations and high-net-worth individuals. Despite the potential for recouping significant revenue, the administration proceeded with the firings, leading to a loss of expertise within the agency. The IRS had been preparing to hire thousands of new enforcement and customer service personnel, but many of these new hires were still in their probationary period. This meant they were particularly vulnerable to the administration’s cost-cutting measures. These actions were met with criticism from current and former IRS employees, who argued that cutting staff would ultimately lead to less revenue being collected. John Koskinen, who led the IRS from 2013 to 2017, noted that reducing the IRS’s capabilities contradicted the administration’s stated goal of fiscal responsibility. He questioned why an administration interested in curbing the deficit would cut back on the revenue side of the equation.

4. Did Cutting IRS Staff Save Taxpayer Money?

No, cutting IRS staff did not save taxpayer money; economic studies show that for every dollar spent by the IRS, the agency returns between $5 and $12, depending on the taxpayer’s income. Reducing IRS staff leads to less revenue collected and fewer tax abuses detected.

For instance, a 2024 report by the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office found that the IRS found savings of $13,000 for every additional hour spent auditing the tax returns of very wealthy taxpayers. This high return on investment underscores the financial benefits of adequately funding the IRS. The widespread cuts to the IRS, therefore, appear counterproductive to the goal of fiscal responsibility. By reducing the IRS’s ability to audit and enforce tax laws, the government risks losing significant revenue that could otherwise be used to fund public services or reduce the national debt. Moreover, a former LB&I revenue agent added that their work didn’t always lead to the IRS recouping money from a taxpayer; sometimes, they audited a return only to find that the taxpayer was owed more money than they had expected. In the words of the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, this return on investment “would leave Wall Street hedge fund managers drooling.” The argument is that investing in the IRS is not just about catching tax cheats but also about ensuring that taxpayers pay the correct amount, which ultimately benefits the government’s financial health. The Trump administration’s decision to cut IRS staff, therefore, appears to be a short-sighted approach that undermines the agency’s ability to generate revenue and enforce tax laws effectively.

5. What Is the Large Business and International (LB&I) Division?

The Large Business and International (LB&I) division of the IRS audits companies with more than $10 million in assets and high-income individuals. This division has the highest return on investment within the IRS, making it a crucial component of revenue collection.

LB&I employs specialized personnel, such as petroleum engineers, computer scientists, and experts in corporate partnerships, who consult on complex tax returns. These experts help determine whether taxpayers properly claim certain credits or other tax breaks, ensuring compliance with tax laws. According to current and former IRS employees, the taxpayers they audited included pharmaceutical companies, oil and gas companies, construction firms, and major technology corporations, as well as more obscure private corporations and high-net-worth individuals. The LB&I division’s work is essential in cases involving substantial research tax credits, syndicated conservation easements, and other complex tax schemes. These are areas where revenue agents often lack the necessary technical expertise to conduct thorough audits. The division also focuses on ensuring that large businesses and wealthy individuals do not exploit loopholes or engage in abusive tax avoidance schemes. Due to its high return on investment, cuts to the LB&I division have a particularly significant impact on the IRS’s ability to collect revenue. The elimination of about 120 LB&I engineers during the Trump administration, out of a total of roughly 260, underscores the severity of these cuts. Experts and former IRS officials argue that these reductions will lead to less scrutiny of corporations and wealthy individuals, resulting in more risk-taking and less money flowing into the U.S. treasury. The division’s role in ensuring fair tax practices makes it a critical component of the IRS and the government’s financial stability.

6. What Are Syndicated Conservation Easements?

Syndicated conservation easements are tax breaks that have been frequently abused, involving complex transactions where investors purchase land, donate a conservation easement, and then claim inflated deductions. Both Democrats and Republicans have criticized this practice, and the IRS has included it on its list of “Dirty Dozen” tax scams.

These easements involve landowners agreeing to restrict the use of their land in perpetuity to protect its natural resources, such as wildlife habitats or scenic views. In return, they receive a tax deduction based on the land’s appraised value. However, in syndicated conservation easement schemes, promoters artificially inflate the land’s value to generate larger tax deductions for investors. These schemes often involve marketing conservation easements as investment opportunities, promising significant tax benefits to participants. The IRS has challenged many of these transactions, arguing that the claimed deductions are excessive and not supported by legitimate appraisals. The complexity of these schemes requires specialized expertise to uncover and prosecute, making the work of IRS engineers and appraisers essential in combating this form of tax abuse. According to Jack McCumber, an LB&I senior appraiser in Seattle who got fired about six weeks before the end of his probationary status, he and his mentor often worked on syndicated conservative easement cases that could recoup tens and even hundreds of millions of dollars. The abuse of syndicated conservation easements has led to significant revenue losses for the government, prompting increased scrutiny and enforcement efforts by the IRS.

7. How Did the Trump Administration’s Actions Affect IRS Training and Expertise?

The Trump administration’s firings of probationary employees in the IRS, many of whom were new specialists, wiped out decades of experience and institutional knowledge that cannot easily be replaced. This disrupted training programs and reduced the agency’s overall expertise.

These probationary employees had been the focus of extensive training and mentorship efforts, as the IRS had recently expanded its hiring in anticipation of increased funding. Vanessa Rollins, an engineer in the IRS’ Chicago office who was recently fired, noted that probationary employees in LB&I outnumbered full-time staffers in her office. The firings disproportionately affected these newly trained specialists, undermining the agency’s efforts to build a more skilled workforce. The loss of experienced personnel, including mentors who took early retirement in response to the firings, further exacerbated the situation. This reduction in expertise makes it more difficult for the IRS to effectively audit complex tax returns and detect tax abuses. The result, according to experts and former IRS officials, is that corporations and wealthy individuals face far less scrutiny, leading to more risk-taking and less money flowing into the U.S. treasury. The administration’s actions not only reduced the agency’s current capabilities but also hindered its ability to develop future expertise and maintain institutional knowledge.

8. What Is the Potential Long-Term Impact of These IRS Cuts?

The long-term impact of the IRS cuts includes reduced scrutiny of tax returns, increased risk-taking by corporations and wealthy individuals, and less revenue flowing into the U.S. treasury. These cuts may also lead to a decline in taxpayer compliance and a perception that tax laws are not being enforced effectively.

With fewer auditors and specialists, the IRS has less capacity to thoroughly examine complex tax returns, particularly those filed by large businesses and high-income individuals. This lack of oversight can create opportunities for tax evasion and avoidance, potentially costing the government billions of dollars in lost revenue. As former IRS Commissioner John Koskinen pointed out, when audits stop because there isn’t anybody to do them, people will say, ‘Hey, I did that last year, I’ll do it again this year.’ Moreover, the reduction in IRS staff can lead to delays in processing tax returns and resolving taxpayer issues, further eroding public trust in the agency. The long-term consequences of these cuts extend beyond immediate revenue losses, potentially undermining the integrity of the tax system and creating a culture of non-compliance.

9. How Much Did DOGE Claim to Have Saved Taxpayers?

DOGE, referring to a U.S. DOGE Service team of lawyers and engineers, claimed to have found savings of $55 billion over the next year. However, a Wall Street Journal analysis found that DOGE had found savings of $2.6 billion over the next year, far less than the amount claimed by DOGE itself.

Musk asked his followers on X, the platform he owns, whether they would “like @DOGE to audit the IRS,” referring to the U.S. DOGE Service team of lawyers and engineers led by him. DOGE employees have sought to gain access to IRS taxpayer data in an attempt to “shine a light on the fraud,” according to a White House spokesman. The discrepancy between these figures highlights the importance of verifying claims of cost savings and assessing the actual impact of government initiatives. It also underscores the potential for overstating the benefits of certain programs or policies. While DOGE aimed to identify fraud and reduce government waste, the actual financial impact of its efforts appears to be significantly less than initially reported.

10. What Can Taxpayers Do to Stay Informed and Manage Their Finances?

Taxpayers can stay informed by following reputable news sources, consulting with financial advisors, and using resources like savewhere.net to understand tax policies and manage their finances effectively. Being proactive and informed can help taxpayers make sound financial decisions and navigate the complexities of the tax system.

At savewhere.net, we provide valuable insights and tips on how to save money, manage your budget, and understand tax-related issues. Our resources are designed to empower you with the knowledge you need to make informed decisions about your finances. Additionally, it’s essential to keep track of changes in tax laws and regulations, as these can impact your tax obligations and financial planning. Consulting with a qualified tax professional can provide personalized advice and ensure that you are taking advantage of all available deductions and credits. By staying informed and proactive, taxpayers can protect their financial interests and make the most of their resources.

11. What Role Does Political Affiliation Play in Discussions About Taxpayer Savings?

Political affiliation often shapes the narrative around taxpayer savings, with different parties highlighting different priorities and approaches to fiscal policy. Understanding these perspectives is crucial for a balanced view of government spending and its impact on taxpayers.

For example, Republicans may emphasize tax cuts and deregulation as ways to stimulate economic growth and reduce the tax burden on individuals and businesses. Democrats, on the other hand, may prioritize investments in social programs and infrastructure, arguing that these investments benefit society as a whole and promote long-term economic stability. The Trump administration’s focus on cutting government spending and reducing the size of the federal workforce reflects a particular ideological perspective on the role of government and its impact on the economy. Similarly, criticisms of these policies from Democrats and other groups reflect differing views on the appropriate level of government intervention and the importance of public services. By recognizing these political dynamics, taxpayers can better evaluate the claims and counterclaims made by different parties and make more informed decisions about their own financial well-being.

12. How Can You Verify Claims About Taxpayer Savings Made by Politicians?

To verify claims about taxpayer savings made by politicians, cross-reference information with nonpartisan sources such as the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the Government Accountability Office (GAO), and reputable news organizations. These sources provide independent analysis and data that can help you assess the accuracy of political claims.

These organizations offer unbiased assessments of the potential impact of proposed policies on the federal budget and the economy. Additionally, it’s essential to be skeptical of claims that lack specific details or are based on overly optimistic assumptions. Look for evidence-based analysis and data that support the claims being made. Consulting with financial experts and tax professionals can also provide valuable insights and help you understand the potential impact of different policies on your own finances. By critically evaluating the information presented and seeking out independent sources of verification, you can make more informed decisions about the claims made by politicians regarding taxpayer savings.

13. What Are Some Common Misconceptions About Taxpayer Savings?

Common misconceptions about taxpayer savings include the belief that all government spending is wasteful, that cutting taxes always leads to economic growth, and that reducing the size of government automatically results in greater efficiency. These misconceptions often oversimplify complex issues and can lead to misguided policy decisions.

For example, while some government programs may be inefficient or ineffective, many others provide essential services and contribute to the overall well-being of society. Similarly, while tax cuts can stimulate economic activity under certain circumstances, they may also exacerbate income inequality and lead to budget deficits. Moreover, reducing the size of government without careful consideration of the potential consequences can result in the loss of valuable expertise and a decline in public services. By recognizing these common misconceptions and adopting a more nuanced understanding of the issues, taxpayers can make more informed decisions about fiscal policy and government spending.

14. How Does Government Efficiency Impact Taxpayer Savings?

Government efficiency directly impacts taxpayer savings by ensuring that public resources are used effectively and that programs deliver the intended outcomes at the lowest possible cost. Improving government efficiency can lead to reduced waste, increased productivity, and better value for taxpayer dollars.

This involves streamlining processes, eliminating redundancies, and adopting best practices from the private sector. Investing in technology and innovation can also enhance government efficiency and improve service delivery. Additionally, holding government agencies accountable for their performance and establishing clear metrics for success can help ensure that public resources are used wisely. By focusing on government efficiency, policymakers can maximize the impact of taxpayer dollars and improve the overall effectiveness of government programs.

15. What Are the Best Ways to Save Money as a Taxpayer?

The best ways to save money as a taxpayer include taking advantage of all available deductions and credits, planning your finances carefully, and staying informed about changes in tax laws. Making smart financial decisions and seeking professional advice can help you minimize your tax burden and maximize your savings.

This includes contributing to retirement accounts, such as 401(k)s and IRAs, which offer tax advantages and can help you save for the future. You can make sure you are getting the best deals on your purchases, which can save you money. You can also save money by shopping around for insurance, negotiating lower rates on your bills, and reducing unnecessary expenses. Additionally, consider starting a side hustle. By taking these steps and staying proactive about your finances, you can save money as a taxpayer and achieve your financial goals. Remember, savewhere.net is here to help you with the latest tips and resources for saving money and managing your finances effectively.

16. How Can I Stay Updated on Tax Law Changes and Their Impact on Savings?

Staying updated on tax law changes and their impact on savings involves regularly consulting reputable news sources, subscribing to updates from the IRS, and seeking advice from financial professionals. Staying informed ensures you can adjust your financial strategies to maximize savings and minimize tax liabilities.

The IRS website is a reliable source for official updates and guidance on tax law changes. Subscribing to their email alerts ensures you receive timely notifications about important developments. Professional financial advisors and tax consultants can offer personalized advice based on your specific financial situation and help you navigate complex tax laws. Additionally, following reputable financial news outlets and publications can provide valuable insights into the potential impact of tax law changes on your savings and investments. By staying informed through these channels, you can make informed decisions and optimize your financial strategies to achieve your savings goals.

17. What Are Some Overlooked Tax Deductions That Can Help Save Money?

Some often-overlooked tax deductions that can help save money include deductions for home office expenses, student loan interest, medical expenses, and charitable contributions. Taking advantage of these deductions can significantly reduce your taxable income and lower your overall tax burden.

For example, if you work from home, you may be able to deduct expenses such as rent, utilities, and internet costs. You can also check out energy credits. Student loan interest payments are often deductible, even if you are not currently itemizing your deductions. You can only deduct the amount of your medical expenses that exceeds 7.5% of your adjusted gross income. If you donate to qualified charities, you can deduct the fair market value of your contributions. By carefully reviewing your financial situation and exploring these often-overlooked deductions, you can potentially save a significant amount of money on your taxes.

18. How Does Inflation Affect Taxpayer Savings, and What Can Be Done?

Inflation erodes the value of taxpayer savings by reducing purchasing power and diminishing the real return on investments. To mitigate the impact of inflation, taxpayers can invest in assets that tend to outpace inflation, such as stocks, real estate, and Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS).

Diversifying your investment portfolio can help protect your savings from the effects of inflation. Investing in TIPS, which are indexed to inflation, can provide a hedge against rising prices. You can also consider investing in commodities and other assets that tend to perform well during inflationary periods. Additionally, it’s essential to regularly review your investment strategy and adjust it as needed to account for changes in inflation and market conditions. By taking proactive steps to manage the impact of inflation, taxpayers can preserve the value of their savings and achieve their financial goals.

19. How Can Budgeting Help Taxpayers Save Money Effectively?

Budgeting helps taxpayers save money effectively by providing a clear framework for tracking income and expenses, identifying areas where spending can be reduced, and setting financial goals. Creating and adhering to a budget can lead to increased savings, reduced debt, and improved financial stability.

This involves creating a detailed plan for how you will allocate your income each month. It also helps you identify areas where you may be overspending or wasting money. You can use budgeting to set specific financial goals, such as saving for a down payment on a home, paying off debt, or investing for retirement. There are many budgeting apps and tools available to help you track your spending and manage your finances effectively. You can also seek advice from a financial advisor to create a personalized budget that aligns with your financial goals and circumstances. By taking the time to create and maintain a budget, you can gain greater control over your finances and achieve your savings goals.

20. What Are Some Common Budgeting Mistakes to Avoid for Better Savings?

Common budgeting mistakes to avoid for better savings include failing to track expenses accurately, setting unrealistic goals, neglecting to plan for unexpected expenses, and not reviewing and adjusting the budget regularly. Avoiding these mistakes can lead to more effective budgeting and greater savings.

Accurately tracking your expenses is essential for identifying areas where you may be overspending. Make sure to record all of your income and expenses, even small purchases. Setting unrealistic goals can lead to frustration and discouragement. Set achievable goals and break them down into smaller, manageable steps. You should plan for unexpected expenses, such as car repairs or medical bills. You should review and adjust your budget regularly to account for changes in your income, expenses, and financial goals. By avoiding these common budgeting mistakes and adopting sound financial practices, you can improve your savings and achieve greater financial stability.

21. What Strategies Can Families Use to Save Money on Daily Expenses?

Families can use various strategies to save money on daily expenses, such as meal planning, buying in bulk, using coupons and discounts, and reducing energy consumption. Implementing these strategies can lead to significant savings over time.

By planning meals in advance, you can reduce food waste and avoid impulse purchases. You can save money by buying in bulk, particularly for non-perishable items. Coupons and discounts can help you save money on groceries, clothing, and other household items. Reducing energy consumption, such as turning off lights and appliances when not in use, can lower your utility bills. By implementing these strategies, families can save money on daily expenses and improve their overall financial well-being.

22. How Does Debt Management Impact Taxpayer Savings and Financial Health?

Effective debt management significantly impacts taxpayer savings and financial health by reducing interest payments, freeing up cash flow, and improving credit scores. Managing debt wisely can lead to increased savings, reduced financial stress, and greater financial stability.

This involves creating a plan to pay off debt as quickly as possible while minimizing interest charges. Strategies such as the debt snowball method or the debt avalanche method can help you prioritize and pay off your debts effectively. Avoiding unnecessary debt and making informed borrowing decisions can also help improve your financial health. Additionally, maintaining a good credit score can lead to lower interest rates on loans and credit cards, saving you money in the long run. By managing debt effectively, taxpayers can improve their financial health and increase their savings potential.

23. What Are the Key Benefits of Investing Early for Long-Term Taxpayer Savings?

The key benefits of investing early for long-term taxpayer savings include the power of compounding, tax-advantaged accounts, and the ability to weather market fluctuations. Starting early allows your investments to grow exponentially over time, providing greater financial security and savings.

The earlier you start investing, the more time your investments have to grow through compounding. Tax-advantaged accounts, such as 401(k)s and IRAs, offer tax benefits that can significantly increase your savings over time. Investing early also allows you to weather market fluctuations, as you have more time to recover from any losses. By starting early and taking advantage of these benefits, taxpayers can maximize their savings and achieve their long-term financial goals.

24. How Can Financial Literacy Education Improve Taxpayer Savings and Financial Decisions?

Financial literacy education improves taxpayer savings and financial decisions by providing individuals with the knowledge and skills to make informed choices about budgeting, saving, investing, and managing debt. Increased financial literacy can lead to better financial outcomes and greater financial security.

Financial literacy education can help individuals understand basic financial concepts, such as compound interest, inflation, and diversification. It can also provide practical skills for creating a budget, managing debt, and investing for the future. You can also learn how to spot financial scams. Moreover, financial literacy education can empower individuals to take control of their finances and make informed decisions that align with their financial goals.

25. What Resources Does Savewhere.net Offer to Help Taxpayers Save Money?

Savewhere.net offers a variety of resources to help taxpayers save money, including expert tips on budgeting, saving, and investing, as well as information on tax deductions, credits, and financial planning. Our goal is to provide you with the tools and knowledge you need to make smart financial decisions and achieve your savings goals.

Our website features articles, guides, and calculators designed to help you manage your finances effectively. We also provide information on the latest tax laws and regulations, as well as tips on how to maximize your tax savings. Additionally, we offer resources for creating a budget, managing debt, and investing for the future. Our goal is to empower you with the knowledge and tools you need to take control of your finances and achieve your financial goals. Visit savewhere.net today to explore our resources and start saving money effectively.


FAQ: Trump’s Impact on Taxpayer Savings

1. Did Trump really save taxpayers money?

The claim that Trump saved taxpayers money is complex. While his administration aimed to cut government spending, studies suggest that some actions, like IRS staff cuts, actually reduced revenue collection.

2. How did Trump try to save taxpayer dollars?

Trump’s administration attempted to reduce government spending by targeting probationary employees, proposing budget cuts, and aiming to shrink the federal workforce.

3. What was the impact of Trump’s policies on the IRS?

Trump’s policies led to significant staff reductions at the IRS, including the firing of over 6,000 employees, which experts argue reduced the agency’s ability to collect revenue.

4. Did cutting IRS staff lead to taxpayer savings?

No, cutting IRS staff did not save taxpayer money. Economic studies show that for every dollar spent by the IRS, the agency returns between $5 and $12.

5. What is the LB&I division of the IRS?

The LB&I division audits companies with over $10 million in assets and high-income individuals, playing a crucial role in revenue collection.

6. Were syndicated conservation easements a problem during Trump’s presidency?

Yes, syndicated conservation easements, a type of tax break that has been frequently abused, were a concern, leading to scrutiny by the IRS.

7. How did Trump’s actions affect IRS training and expertise?

The firings of probationary employees disrupted training programs and led to a loss of valuable expertise within the IRS.

8. What is the long-term impact of the IRS cuts under Trump?

The long-term impact includes reduced scrutiny of tax returns, increased risk-taking by corporations and wealthy individuals, and less revenue for the U.S. treasury.

9. How can taxpayers stay informed about tax policies?

Taxpayers can stay informed by following reputable news sources, consulting with financial advisors, and using resources like savewhere.net.

10. Where can I find more information about saving money on taxes?

You can find more information about saving money on taxes and managing your finances at savewhere.net, which offers expert tips and resources.

Ready to start saving money and managing your finances more effectively? Visit savewhere.net today to explore our resources and connect with a community of like-minded individuals in the USA. Discover valuable tips, find exclusive deals, and take control of your financial future!

Address: 100 Peachtree St NW, Atlanta, GA 30303, United States
Phone: +1 (404) 656-2000
Website: savewhere.net

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *