Can I Save Isobel From Marcus in Baldur’s Gate 3? Yes, saving Isobel from Marcus in Baldur’s Gate 3 is possible and recommended for a richer gaming experience. At savewhere.net, we provide you with tips and strategies to successfully protect Isobel, secure the Last Light Inn, and unlock essential quests. Discover effective tactics and character builds to manage your resources wisely, ensuring a triumphant outcome in this critical encounter.
Table of Contents
1. Understanding the Stakes: Why Saving Isobel Matters
2. Preparing for the Battle: Essential Steps Before the Encounter
3. Strategic Positioning: Gaining the Upper Hand
4. Combat Tactics: How to Beat Marcus and His Minions
5. Class and Character Builds: Optimizing Your Party for Success
6. Essential Spells and Abilities: Turning the Tide of Battle
7. Managing Resources: Health Potions, Scrolls, and More
8. The Consequences of Failure: What Happens If You Can’t Save Isobel?
9. Alternative Strategies: Exploring Different Approaches to the Encounter
10. The Aftermath: Rewards and Next Steps
11. Community Tips and Tricks: Learn From Other Players
12. Conclusion: Mastering the Art of Saving Isobel
13. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Understanding the Stakes: Why Saving Isobel Matters
Saving Isobel in Baldur’s Gate 3 is critical due to the significant impact her survival has on the game’s narrative and your progression. Isobel, a cleric gifted by the goddess Selûne, maintains a powerful light ward around the Last Light Inn. This ward protects everyone in the area from the Shadow Curse, a pervasive and deadly force in the Shadow-Cursed Lands. Her safety ensures the well-being of the inn’s inhabitants and unlocks numerous quests and story arcs.
1.1. The Importance of the Light Ward
The light ward Isobel maintains is the sole protection against the Shadow Curse. Without it, the Last Light Inn falls, and its residents succumb to the curse, leading to dire consequences. According to in-game lore, the curse transforms living beings into twisted, shadow-corrupted creatures, making the area uninhabitable.
1.2. Questlines and Character Development
Saving Isobel unlocks several important questlines, including those involving key characters like Karlach and Shadowheart. For example, Karlach’s questline progresses significantly with Isobel’s survival, allowing you to further develop her story and unlock unique abilities. Similarly, Shadowheart’s quest benefits from Isobel’s presence, providing deeper insights into her past and her relationship with Shar.
1.3. Impact on the Refugee Tieflings
The refugee Tieflings, seeking shelter at the Last Light Inn, depend on Isobel’s ward for their survival. If Isobel is captured or killed, the Tieflings are left vulnerable to the Shadow Curse, leading to their demise or corruption. This outcome affects the overall narrative, particularly if you’ve invested in their well-being.
1.4. Strategic Advantages
Keeping Isobel safe offers strategic advantages, allowing you to explore the Shadow-Cursed Lands with less risk. The light ward provides a safe haven, enabling you to rest, resupply, and plan your next move without the constant threat of the Shadow Curse. This is particularly useful when navigating dangerous areas and engaging in challenging battles.
1.5. Moral and Ethical Considerations
Choosing to save Isobel aligns with a morally upright path, reflecting heroism and compassion. This decision resonates with players who value these traits in their characters and seek to create a positive impact on the game world. Saving Isobel not only benefits your party but also reinforces the themes of hope and resilience against overwhelming darkness.
2. Preparing for the Battle: Essential Steps Before the Encounter
Proper preparation is essential for successfully saving Isobel from Marcus in Baldur’s Gate 3. This encounter is challenging, and going in unprepared can lead to failure and significant consequences.
2.1. Level and Equipment Check
Ensure your party is at an appropriate level for the encounter. Aim to be at least level 6 or higher before attempting to save Isobel. Check your equipment to ensure everyone has the best available armor, weapons, and accessories. According to game guides, having upgraded gear significantly improves your party’s survivability and damage output.
2.2. Party Composition
Consider your party composition carefully. A balanced team with a tank, damage dealers, and a healer is ideal. Karlach, with her high hit points and damage resistance, makes an excellent tank. Astarion or another rogue can provide crucial damage output, while Shadowheart or a cleric can keep your party alive with healing spells.
2.3. Dialogue and Exploration
Before heading upstairs to see Isobel, exhaust all available dialogue options with other characters in the Last Light Inn. Talking to Dammon, Jaheira, Mol, and Raphael can provide valuable insights, quest updates, and potentially unlock additional resources. Thorough exploration ensures you don’t miss any hidden advantages.
2.4. Creating a Save File
Before initiating the conversation with Isobel, create a save file. This allows you to reload and try different strategies if the initial encounter goes poorly. According to player feedback, having a save file is crucial for experimenting with different tactics and optimizing your approach.
2.5. Stocking Up on Consumables
Stock up on essential consumables such as health potions, scrolls, and grenades. Health potions are critical for keeping your party alive during the fight. Scrolls, such as those providing temporary buffs or additional damage, can turn the tide of battle. Grenades can provide area-of-effect damage, helping you control the battlefield.
2.6. Understanding Enemy Weaknesses
Research the weaknesses of Marcus and his minions. Knowing their vulnerabilities can help you tailor your attacks and maximize your damage output. For instance, if Marcus is vulnerable to radiant damage, equipping weapons or spells that deal radiant damage can significantly reduce his health.
2.7. Buffing Your Party
Before engaging Marcus, buff your party with beneficial spells and abilities. Bless, Shield of Faith, and other protective spells can increase your party’s defenses and improve their chances of survival. Buffs that enhance attack rolls and damage output can also provide a significant advantage.
3. Strategic Positioning: Gaining the Upper Hand
Strategic positioning is key to gaining the upper hand in the battle to save Isobel. Where your party members are located at the start of the fight and how you move them during combat can significantly impact the outcome.
3.1. Pre-Battle Setup
Before initiating the dialogue with Isobel, position the bulk of your party upstairs near her. This ensures they are ready to engage Marcus and his minions immediately when the fight begins. According to experienced players, having your party spread out downstairs can waste valuable turns getting into position.
3.2. Surrounding Isobel
Once the fight starts, surround Isobel with your party members. This creates a protective barrier, making it more difficult for enemies to reach her. A tank like Karlach should be positioned directly in front of Isobel, absorbing the brunt of the enemy attacks.
3.3. High Ground Advantage
Utilize the high ground available in Isobel’s room. Characters positioned on the balcony or elevated platforms gain an advantage in attack rolls and can target enemies more effectively. Ranged characters like archers and spellcasters should take advantage of this high ground.
3.4. Chokepoints and Bottlenecks
Identify and utilize chokepoints and bottlenecks in the room. These narrow passages can funnel enemies, allowing your party to focus their attacks and control the flow of combat. Positioning your tank at a chokepoint can effectively block enemy advancement.
3.5. Controlling the Battlefield
Use spells and abilities to control the battlefield. Spells like Grease, Web, and Entangle can slow or immobilize enemies, giving your party more time to focus on key targets. Area-of-effect spells can also disrupt enemy formations and deal significant damage.
3.6. Prioritizing Targets
Prioritize your targets strategically. Focus on eliminating Marcus first, as he poses the greatest threat to Isobel. Once Marcus is down, shift your focus to the other enemies, prioritizing those that pose the greatest threat to your party or Isobel.
3.7. Maintaining Awareness
Maintain awareness of the entire battlefield. Keep an eye on the positions of your party members, Isobel, and the enemies. Adjust your strategy as needed to respond to changing circumstances. Communication and coordination are key to maintaining control of the battlefield.
4. Combat Tactics: How to Beat Marcus and His Minions
Effective combat tactics are crucial for defeating Marcus and his minions and saving Isobel. This encounter requires a combination of strategic planning, tactical execution, and adaptability.
4.1. Focusing on Marcus
Your primary objective is to defeat Marcus as quickly as possible. He poses the greatest threat to Isobel, and his defeat significantly reduces the pressure on your party. Focus all your offensive abilities on him, using your strongest attacks and spells.
4.2. Utilizing Crowd Control
Employ crowd control abilities to manage the other enemies. Spells like Hold Person, Tasha’s Hideous Laughter, and Command can incapacitate enemies, preventing them from attacking Isobel or your party members. Prioritize using crowd control on the most dangerous enemies.
4.3. Protecting Isobel
Isobel is vulnerable during the fight, and her health must be protected at all costs. Position your tank in front of her, absorbing the brunt of the enemy attacks. Use healing spells and abilities to keep her alive and healthy.
4.4. Damage Output Optimization
Optimize your damage output by exploiting enemy weaknesses and using abilities that enhance your attacks. If Marcus is vulnerable to radiant damage, equip weapons or spells that deal radiant damage. Use abilities like Hunter’s Mark or Hex to increase your damage output against specific targets.
4.5. Interrupting Enemy Actions
Interrupt enemy actions whenever possible. Spells like Counterspell or abilities like Cutting Words can disrupt enemy spellcasting or attacks, preventing them from dealing damage or using powerful abilities. Prioritize interrupting actions that target Isobel.
4.6. Strategic Retreats
If a party member is taking too much damage, consider a strategic retreat. Move them to a safer location where they can heal and recover before rejoining the fight. Use healing potions or spells to restore their health quickly.
4.7. Adaptive Strategies
Be prepared to adapt your strategy as needed. The battle against Marcus can be unpredictable, and you may need to adjust your tactics based on the changing circumstances. Stay flexible and be ready to respond to unexpected events.
5. Class and Character Builds: Optimizing Your Party for Success
Optimizing your party’s class and character builds can significantly increase your chances of success in the battle to save Isobel. A well-balanced and strategically built party can overcome the challenges posed by Marcus and his minions.
5.1. Tank: Karlach
Karlach makes an excellent tank due to her high hit points, damage resistance, and powerful melee attacks. Equip her with heavy armor and a shield to maximize her survivability. Focus on abilities that draw enemy attention and protect your allies.
5.2. Damage Dealer: Astarion
Astarion, as a rogue, can provide significant damage output with his sneak attacks and critical hits. Equip him with dual daggers and focus on abilities that increase his damage and mobility. Position him strategically to take advantage of flanking opportunities.
5.3. Healer: Shadowheart
Shadowheart, as a cleric, is essential for keeping your party alive with her healing spells and support abilities. Equip her with armor that enhances her spellcasting and focus on abilities that restore health and provide protection.
5.4. Support: Gale
Gale, as a wizard, can provide valuable support with his crowd control spells and area-of-effect damage. Equip him with robes that enhance his spellcasting and focus on abilities that immobilize enemies and disrupt their formations.
BG3's character selection interface, highlighting strategic party composition and the importance of character-specific equipment
5.5. Multiclassing Considerations
Consider multiclassing to enhance your party’s capabilities. For example, multiclassing Karlach into a barbarian can further increase her damage output and survivability. Multiclassing Astarion into a ranger can provide him with additional ranged attacks and utility abilities.
5.6. Feat Selection
Choose feats that complement your party’s strengths and mitigate their weaknesses. Feats like Sentinel, Great Weapon Master, and War Caster can significantly enhance your party’s combat effectiveness.
5.7. Gear Optimization
Optimize your party’s gear by equipping them with items that enhance their key abilities and attributes. Look for items that increase strength, dexterity, constitution, intelligence, wisdom, and charisma. Also, prioritize items that provide bonuses to attack rolls, damage output, and saving throws.
6. Essential Spells and Abilities: Turning the Tide of Battle
Utilizing the right spells and abilities at the right time can turn the tide of battle in your favor. Knowing which spells and abilities are most effective against Marcus and his minions is crucial for success.
6.1. Healing Spells
Healing spells are essential for keeping your party alive and protecting Isobel. Cure Wounds, Healing Word, and Mass Healing Word are all valuable options. Prioritize using healing spells on party members who are taking the most damage.
6.2. Crowd Control Spells
Crowd control spells can immobilize enemies, preventing them from attacking Isobel or your party members. Hold Person, Tasha’s Hideous Laughter, and Command are all effective options. Use crowd control spells on the most dangerous enemies.
6.3. Damage Spells
Damage spells can deal significant damage to Marcus and his minions. Fireball, Lightning Bolt, and Ice Storm are all powerful options. Use damage spells strategically to target multiple enemies at once.
6.4. Buffing Spells
Buffing spells can enhance your party’s abilities and increase their chances of success. Bless, Shield of Faith, and Haste are all valuable options. Use buffing spells before engaging Marcus to give your party a significant advantage.
6.5. Defensive Abilities
Defensive abilities can protect your party from enemy attacks and increase their survivability. Shield, Absorb Elements, and Mirror Image are all effective options. Use defensive abilities strategically to mitigate damage and protect vulnerable party members.
6.6. Utility Spells
Utility spells can provide valuable support and control the battlefield. Grease, Web, and Entangle can slow or immobilize enemies, giving your party more time to focus on key targets. Misty Step and Dimension Door can provide mobility and allow your party to reposition quickly.
6.7. Interrupting Abilities
Interrupting abilities can disrupt enemy spellcasting or attacks, preventing them from dealing damage or using powerful abilities. Counterspell and Cutting Words are both effective options. Prioritize interrupting actions that target Isobel.
7. Managing Resources: Health Potions, Scrolls, and More
Effective resource management is essential for surviving the battle to save Isobel. Knowing when to use health potions, scrolls, and other consumables can make the difference between victory and defeat.
7.1. Health Potions
Health potions are critical for restoring health during the fight. Keep a supply of health potions on hand and use them whenever a party member’s health drops low. Prioritize using health potions on party members who are taking the most damage.
7.2. Scrolls
Scrolls can provide temporary buffs or additional damage. Keep a supply of scrolls on hand and use them strategically to enhance your party’s abilities. Scrolls that provide resistance to damage or increase attack rolls can be particularly useful.
7.3. Grenades
Grenades can provide area-of-effect damage, helping you control the battlefield. Keep a supply of grenades on hand and use them to disrupt enemy formations and deal significant damage. Grenades that deal fire or acid damage can be particularly effective.
7.4. Food and Drink
Food and drink can provide temporary buffs to your party’s abilities. Eat or drink before engaging Marcus to give your party a slight advantage. Food and drink that increase strength, dexterity, or constitution can be particularly useful.
7.5. Long Rest Management
Manage your long rests strategically. Long rests restore your party’s health and spell slots, but they also advance the game’s timeline. Avoid taking unnecessary long rests and plan your rests carefully to ensure you are always prepared for the next encounter.
7.6. Short Rest Utilization
Utilize short rests to restore your party’s hit points and abilities. Short rests are quicker than long rests and do not advance the game’s timeline. Use short rests whenever your party needs a quick boost.
7.7. Gold Management
Manage your gold carefully. Use your gold to purchase essential consumables and equipment. Avoid spending gold on unnecessary items. Save your gold for the most important purchases.
8. The Consequences of Failure: What Happens If You Can’t Save Isobel?
Failing to save Isobel has significant and far-reaching consequences in Baldur’s Gate 3. The Last Light Inn falls, and the Shadow Curse intensifies, leading to a cascade of negative outcomes that impact various questlines and characters.
8.1. The Fall of Last Light Inn
If Isobel is captured or killed, the light ward protecting the Last Light Inn collapses. Without the ward, the inn and its inhabitants are vulnerable to the Shadow Curse. The inn is overrun by shadow-corrupted creatures, and the survivors are either killed or transformed.
8.2. Impact on the Refugee Tieflings
The refugee Tieflings, who sought shelter at the Last Light Inn, are left without protection. They succumb to the Shadow Curse, leading to their demise or transformation into shadow-corrupted creatures. This outcome has a significant impact on the overall narrative, particularly if you’ve invested in their well-being.
8.3. Questline Interruptions
Failing to save Isobel interrupts several important questlines. Karlach’s questline is significantly affected, preventing you from progressing her story and unlocking her unique abilities. Similarly, Shadowheart’s quest is impacted, limiting your ability to explore her past and her relationship with Shar.
8.4. Closure of Secondary Missions
Several secondary missions are closed off if Isobel is lost. These missions often provide valuable rewards, experience, and story insights. Losing access to these missions can hinder your progress and limit your options.
8.5. Intensified Shadow Curse
The Shadow Curse intensifies throughout the region, making exploration more dangerous. The environment becomes more hostile, and the enemies become more powerful. Navigating the Shadow-Cursed Lands becomes significantly more challenging.
8.6. Loss of Allies
The loss of Isobel and the fall of Last Light Inn can lead to the loss of potential allies. Characters who would have aided you in your quest are either killed or corrupted, reducing your support network and limiting your options.
8.7. Narrative Impact
Failing to save Isobel has a significant narrative impact, creating a darker and more tragic storyline. The game world becomes more oppressive, and the themes of hope and resilience are diminished. This outcome can affect your overall enjoyment of the game, particularly if you value a more optimistic narrative.
9. Alternative Strategies: Exploring Different Approaches to the Encounter
While the primary strategy for saving Isobel involves direct combat with Marcus, there are alternative approaches that players can explore. These strategies may require different character builds, skills, and resources, but they can provide unique and rewarding outcomes.
9.1. Stealth and Deception
Instead of engaging Marcus in direct combat, consider using stealth and deception to avoid the encounter altogether. Use invisibility spells or abilities to sneak past Marcus and his minions. Alternatively, use deception skills to convince Marcus to leave without Isobel.
9.2. Diplomatic Solutions
Explore diplomatic solutions to resolve the conflict with Marcus. Use persuasion or intimidation skills to convince him to change his mind or negotiate a compromise. This approach may require high charisma and well-crafted dialogue choices.
9.3. Utilizing Environmental Hazards
Take advantage of environmental hazards to weaken or eliminate Marcus and his minions. Use spells or abilities to create fires, explosions, or other hazards that can damage or incapacitate enemies. This approach requires careful planning and tactical execution.
9.4. Summoning Allies
Summon allies to aid you in the battle against Marcus. Use spells or abilities to summon creatures that can fight alongside you. This approach can provide additional damage output and help to control the battlefield.
9.5. Pre-emptive Strikes
Launch pre-emptive strikes against Marcus and his minions before they have a chance to react. Use surprise attacks or ambushes to deal significant damage to the enemies before the main battle begins. This approach requires careful planning and strategic positioning.
9.6. Dividing and Conquering
Divide and conquer Marcus and his minions by splitting your party into smaller groups. Each group can focus on eliminating specific targets or controlling specific areas of the battlefield. This approach requires excellent coordination and communication.
9.7. Sacrificial Plays
Consider making sacrificial plays to protect Isobel. Use a party member with high hit points and damage resistance to draw enemy attention away from Isobel. This approach may require sacrificing a party member, but it can ensure Isobel’s survival.
10. The Aftermath: Rewards and Next Steps
Successfully saving Isobel from Marcus in Baldur’s Gate 3 brings significant rewards and opens up new opportunities for your party. The aftermath of this encounter shapes the direction of your quest and impacts the overall narrative.
10.1. Securing the Last Light Inn
Saving Isobel ensures the survival of the Last Light Inn and its inhabitants. The inn remains a safe haven, providing a place to rest, resupply, and plan your next move. The residents of the inn are grateful for your help and may offer valuable rewards or assistance.
10.2. Quest Progression
Saving Isobel allows you to progress several important questlines. Karlach’s questline continues, unlocking new story arcs and abilities. Shadowheart’s questline also progresses, providing deeper insights into her past and her relationship with Shar.
10.3. New Alliances
Saving Isobel can lead to new alliances with other characters. Characters who witnessed your heroism may offer their support, providing valuable resources or assistance in your quest.
10.4. Enhanced Reputation
Saving Isobel enhances your reputation, making you a hero in the eyes of many. This can open up new dialogue options and opportunities, allowing you to influence events and shape the world around you.
10.5. Rewards and Loot
Saving Isobel can result in valuable rewards and loot. You may receive powerful weapons, armor, or other items that enhance your party’s abilities. You may also receive gold or other resources that can aid you in your quest.
10.6. Narrative Satisfaction
Saving Isobel provides a sense of narrative satisfaction, knowing that you have made a positive impact on the game world. The themes of hope and resilience are reinforced, creating a more optimistic and rewarding gaming experience.
10.7. Preparing for the Next Chapter
With Isobel saved and the Last Light Inn secured, you can now prepare for the next chapter of your quest. Explore the Shadow-Cursed Lands, uncover new secrets, and confront the forces of darkness that threaten the region.
11. Community Tips and Tricks: Learn From Other Players
The Baldur’s Gate 3 community is a valuable resource for tips, tricks, and strategies. Learning from other players can provide new insights and help you overcome the challenges of saving Isobel.
11.1. Online Forums and Communities
Engage with online forums and communities dedicated to Baldur’s Gate 3. Share your experiences, ask questions, and learn from other players. These communities often provide detailed guides, walkthroughs, and strategies.
11.2. Video Tutorials and Walkthroughs
Watch video tutorials and walkthroughs created by other players. These videos can provide visual demonstrations of different strategies and tactics. They can also offer insights into character builds, spell selections, and resource management.
11.3. Reddit and Discord
Participate in Reddit and Discord communities dedicated to Baldur’s Gate 3. These platforms provide real-time discussions and allow you to interact directly with other players. You can ask questions, share tips, and receive feedback on your strategies.
11.4. Twitch and YouTube Streams
Watch Twitch and YouTube streams of Baldur’s Gate 3 gameplay. These streams can provide valuable insights into the game’s mechanics and strategies. You can also interact with the streamers and ask them questions.
11.5. Sharing Your Own Strategies
Share your own strategies and experiences with the community. By sharing your knowledge, you can help other players overcome the challenges of saving Isobel and contribute to the collective knowledge of the community.
11.6. Learning from Mistakes
Learn from your mistakes and the mistakes of other players. Analyze your failures and identify areas for improvement. Use this knowledge to refine your strategies and increase your chances of success.
11.7. Experimenting and Innovating
Experiment with different strategies and innovate new approaches. The Baldur’s Gate 3 community is constantly evolving, and new tactics are always being discovered. By experimenting and innovating, you can contribute to the growth and development of the community.
12. Conclusion: Mastering the Art of Saving Isobel
Saving Isobel from Marcus in Baldur’s Gate 3 is a challenging but rewarding endeavor. By understanding the stakes, preparing for the battle, utilizing strategic positioning, employing effective combat tactics, optimizing your party’s builds, managing resources wisely, and learning from the community, you can master the art of saving Isobel and secure a brighter future for the Last Light Inn.
Remember that your decisions have far-reaching consequences in Baldur’s Gate 3. Saving Isobel not only ensures the survival of the inn and its inhabitants but also unlocks new questlines, alliances, and rewards. Embrace the challenge, learn from your experiences, and shape the narrative of your own heroic journey.
At savewhere.net, we are dedicated to providing you with the resources and information you need to succeed in Baldur’s Gate 3. Explore our website for more tips, tricks, and strategies to enhance your gaming experience. Join our community and share your own insights to help other players master the art of saving Isobel.
Contact us at:
Address: 100 Peachtree St NW, Atlanta, GA 30303, United States
Phone: +1 (404) 656-2000
Website: savewhere.net
13. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
13.1. What level should I be to save Isobel?
You should aim to be at least level 6 or higher before attempting to save Isobel. This ensures your party has the necessary abilities and resources to handle the encounter effectively.
13.2. What party composition is best for this fight?
A balanced party with a tank, damage dealers, and a healer is ideal. Karlach (tank), Astarion (damage dealer), and Shadowheart (healer) make a strong core.
13.3. What happens if Isobel dies?
If Isobel dies, the Last Light Inn falls, and the Shadow Curse intensifies. This leads to the demise of the inn’s inhabitants and interrupts several important questlines.
13.4. Can I avoid the fight with Marcus?
Yes, you can attempt to avoid the fight with Marcus by using stealth, deception, or diplomatic solutions. However, these approaches require specific skills and may not always be successful.
13.5. What are the best spells to use in this fight?
Healing spells (Cure Wounds, Healing Word), crowd control spells (Hold Person, Tasha’s Hideous Laughter), and damage spells (Fireball, Lightning Bolt) are all effective.
13.6. How do I protect Isobel during the fight?
Position your tank in front of Isobel and use healing spells to keep her alive. Focus on eliminating Marcus as quickly as possible to reduce the pressure on her.
13.7. What consumables should I bring to the fight?
Bring health potions, scrolls, and grenades. Health potions are critical for restoring health, scrolls can provide temporary buffs, and grenades can deal area-of-effect damage.
13.8. Is it better to focus on Marcus or his minions?
Focus on Marcus first, as he poses the greatest threat to Isobel. Once Marcus is down, shift your focus to the other enemies.
13.9. What rewards do I get for saving Isobel?
Saving Isobel secures the Last Light Inn, progresses important questlines, leads to new alliances, enhances your reputation, and can result in valuable rewards and loot.
13.10. Where can I find more tips and strategies for Baldur’s Gate 3?
Explore savewhere.net for more tips, tricks, and strategies to enhance your gaming experience. Join our community and share your own insights to help other players succeed.
