For those unfamiliar, Owen Gleiberman is a film critic who, in his review of “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” upon its release, reportedly dismissed it as relying on tired stereotypes, awarding it a failing grade. Having finally experienced this Coen Brothers masterpiece firsthand, it’s clear how misguided such initial criticisms were. To think of doubting a film simply based on the opinion of someone who also gave “X-Men” a middling C grade seems almost absurd now. “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” transcends mere entertainment; it’s a cinematic triumph on multiple levels.
While not always a staunch George Clooney admirer, his portrayal in this film is undeniably perfect. His Golden Globe win was not just deserved, but a testament to his captivating performance. Equally memorable is the actor who brought Delmar to life. His genuinely funny facial expressions and iconic lines, such as the unforgettable “We thought…you was…a toad!”, provide consistent delight throughout the movie. The menacing Sheriff serves as a truly effective antagonist, and the powerfully staged KKK rally scene is as thrilling as it is unsettling.
The subtle yet clever allusions to Homer’s Odyssey add a layer of sophisticated charm to the narrative, even if the connection between George Nelson and a specific Odyssey character remains a playful mystery. However, the enchanting Siren sequence and its comical aftermath are brilliantly executed, and John Goodman delivers a noteworthy performance as the cyclopean Big Dan Teague. A standout moment, arguably one of the film’s best, is when the Soggy Bottom Boys perform “Man of Constant Sorrow.” This song is instantly uplifting and should have rightfully claimed the MTV Movie Award for Best Musical Performance.
Therefore, it’s best to disregard the initial lukewarm pronouncements from certain “professional” critics. Instead, simply immerse yourself in the delightful absurdity, lighthearted spirit, and genuine quality that “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” so richly offers. It’s a film that continues to resonate and entertain, proving its enduring cinematic value long after its initial release.
