In a nutshell, “Beneath The Trees Where Nobody Sees” is a horror graphic novel that plunges readers into a world of anthropomorphic animals grappling with deeply unsettling moral dilemmas. Think of it as a darker, more twisted take on animal stories, far removed from the lightheartedness of ‘Zootopia’ and leaning more towards the grim intensity of ‘Dexter’. Prepare to be gripped, chilled, and thoroughly creeped out. This isn’t for the faint of heart, but for those who dare to venture into its shadows, the plot and character development offer a compelling, albeit disturbing, exploration of ethics. While highly recommended for the right audience, be warned, this graphic novel isn’t for everyone.
A Glimpse into Woodbrook’s Dark Heart
Imagine a seemingly idyllic small town named Woodbrook, where everyone knows each other – or so they believe. Samantha Strong, a brown bear and owner of the local hardware store, appears to be a model citizen. However, beneath this facade lies a chilling secret: Samantha is a serial killer. Her carefully constructed golden rule? Never target her neighbors. Instead, she seeks victims in the sprawling city bordering the forest, reasoning that in such a vast place, one less person will hardly be noticed. For years, this system has worked flawlessly.
But the delicate balance of Samantha’s dark world is shattered when a brutal murder occurs within Woodbrook itself. The thought of another killer operating in her territory ignites a wild fury within Samantha. As Sheriff Patterson, quite literally barking up the wrong tree, focuses his investigation in the wrong direction, Samantha realizes the onus is on her to hunt down this rival killer. She must stop them before she is exposed, not just for the murders she didn’t commit, but for the long list of those she did.
This graphic novel compiles the complete six-part series of ‘Beneath the Trees’, a critically acclaimed indie sensation. Finally, readers can experience the entire story without the agonizing wait of cliffhangers – a true blessing for those who crave narrative closure, even in the darkest tales.
The Bizarre Brilliance of Juxtaposition
One of the most unsettling and captivating aspects of “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” is its jarring contrast. The artwork often employs a cutesy style, rendered in soft, pastel hues. This gentle aesthetic clashes violently with the narrative’s grim content, which revolves around psychopathic characters and brutal acts. This bizarre juxtaposition leaves a lasting impression, forcing readers to confront the darkness lurking beneath a deceptively innocent surface. It’s a constant reminder that appearances can be profoundly deceiving, especially beneath the trees where nobody sees the true nature of things.
Alt text: A deceptively gentle illustration of Samantha Strong, a brown bear in an apron, standing in a hardware store, hinting at the hidden darkness beneath her friendly exterior.
The core plot is undeniably brilliant, fulfilling the essential function of a horror-thriller: to rivet readers to the page while simultaneously horrifying them with the chilling psychology of its murderers. The story delves into the disturbing reality of brutality committed without remorse or justification. Samantha’s killings are not driven by revenge, trauma, or any relatable motivation; she simply desires to kill. This unsettling casualness of violence is perhaps the most challenging aspect of the narrative, forcing readers to confront the uncomfortable truth of motiveless evil.
Moral Chaos and Mind-Bending Dilemmas
The introduction of a second killer escalates the brutality, paradoxically casting Samantha in a somewhat more “sane” light. Readers are thrust into a moral quandary, unable to align themselves with Samantha, yet equally repulsed by the new antagonist. This creates a narrative vacuum where traditional allegiances crumble. Who does one root for when the protagonist is an anti-hero and the antagonist, while opposing the anti-hero, is far from heroic? This mind-bending moral ambiguity is a defining feature of “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees”.
The setting of Woodbrook amplifies the story’s eerie atmosphere. It’s a world of organized chaos, where anthropomorphic bears coexist, somewhat strangely, with actual bears in the surrounding forest. Butcher shops display pig heads for sale, despite the presence of pig citizens within the town. Humanized animals keep ordinary animals as pets, blurring the lines of normalcy and creating a deeply unsettling environment. This warped reality contributes significantly to the graphic novel’s overall disturbing impact.
Alt text: A panel depicting a butcher shop in Woodbrook, showcasing the unsettling juxtaposition of anthropomorphic animal citizens and butchered animal carcasses, emphasizing the story’s dark themes.
The characters, all anthropomorphic animals, further enhance the sense of unease. Seeing animals with human traits and flaws is inherently weird, amplifying the story’s unsettling nature. The depiction of the townspeople’s fear and paranoia as a killer stalks their streets is palpable. The graphic novel effectively captures the shifting atmosphere of a small town gripped by terror, translating this emotional shift through its visuals.
A Claustrophobic Reading Experience
Reading “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” can be a genuinely intense experience. The reviewer recounts reading it with their daughter, both finding themselves deeply affected, albeit in different ways. The daughter was more disturbed by the moral vacuum, while the reviewer was more affected by the graphic violence. The experience became so claustrophobic that they had to take a break after the fourth comic, simply to regain a sense of normalcy. This powerful reaction is a testament to the graphic novel’s effective execution in creating a truly disturbing atmosphere. Interestingly, amidst the horror, moments of dark humor emerge, perhaps as a coping mechanism, manifesting as nervous, hysterical laughter rather than genuine amusement.
The ending of “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” is intentionally ambiguous, designed to provoke varied reactions. Given the story’s inherent contradictions and moral complexities, a neat resolution would feel out of place. Readers should not expect closure. Instead, the ending leaves a lingering sense of unease, prompting contemplation and debate rather than offering easy answers. It’s an ending that lingers long after the final page is turned, much like the shadows beneath the trees where nobody sees everything.
Minor Grievances in a Compelling Narrative
Despite its strengths, the reviewer notes two minor criticisms. Firstly, the graphic novel’s intensely discomposing nature was almost overwhelming at times. Secondly, the rationale behind the second killer’s motivations felt somewhat underdeveloped and less convincing than Samantha’s more primal urges.
However, these minor points do not detract significantly from the overall impact. The illustrations perfectly complement the plot, despite the unsettling contrast of light pastels used for such dark subject matter. The anthropomorphic animals are expressively drawn, with subtle distinctions between townspeople and wild animals. The murder scenes are undeniably gruesome, depicted with unflinching detail, a factor that particularly affected the reviewer, perhaps more so due to the victims and perpetrators being animals. The artwork also rewards close attention, with hidden clues embedded within many panels, encouraging readers to look beyond the dialogue bubbles. Even the font style contributes to the immersive experience, with Samantha’s inner thoughts presented in a distinct typeface.
Final Verdict: A Recommendation with Caveats
In conclusion, “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” is a remarkably captivating graphic novel, despite its disturbing content. It boasts a screwed-up yet compelling storyline, excellent illustrations, and ample food for thought. Especially impressive is its streamlined plot development, particularly for a debut series. This graphic novel establishes the author as a talent to watch, even if future works are approached with a degree of trepidation.
Highly recommended for readers who appreciate horror and thriller genres, particularly within the graphic novel medium. This is precisely the kind of book that deserves enthusiastic promotion to the right audience – those who can stomach its darkness and appreciate its unsettling brilliance. However, be forewarned: once experienced, “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” is unlikely to be revisited lightly.
4.25 stars.
Thanks to IDW Publishing for providing the DRC of “Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees” via Edelweiss+. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook
