Heating and cooling represent significant operational expenses for building owners, particularly in commercial real estate. Investing in the right mechanical system tailored to specific needs is crucial for long-term cost reduction. But Where Can Mechanical Systems Be Found and what types are most common in different settings? This article explores the locations and applications of five prevalent mechanical systems, helping you understand where each system is typically utilized and why.
There’s a diverse range of mechanical systems available, each with unique characteristics:
- Variable Air Volume (VAV) rooftop units
- Boiler/chiller systems
- Variant Refrigerant Flow (VRF) systems
- Air-source heat pumps
- Ground-source heat pumps
While some of these systems involve higher upfront investment, the payoff comes in the form of reduced energy consumption and lower maintenance costs over time. Architects, in collaboration with mechanical engineers, play a vital role in analyzing life cycle costs to guide building owners in making informed decisions.
It’s important to recognize that a universal solution doesn’t exist when it comes to mechanical systems. The most economical choice is heavily influenced by the building’s size and its intended purpose. Let’s delve into the five most common mechanical systems and the factors that determine their efficiency and typical locations.
Common Locations of Mechanical Systems
1. Rooftop Units: Variable Air Volume (VAV) Systems
VAV systems are a staple in the world of mechanical systems, often recognized by their rooftop placement. You can commonly find Variable Air Volume (VAV) rooftop units mounted on the roofs of commercial buildings and large residential complexes. These self-contained units are integrated with ductwork to draw in fresh air, condition it, and distribute it throughout the building’s interior.
While primarily known for cooling, many modern rooftop units also incorporate heating capabilities. In heating mode, the system directs air over gas-fired or electric coils before circulating it through the building’s ductwork.
VAV systems are often chosen for their lower initial installation cost, making them attractive for budget-conscious projects. However, the long-term operational costs are directly tied to the unit’s energy efficiency. Generally, opting for a higher-efficiency rooftop unit translates to a greater initial investment but promises better long-term savings.
Traditionally, VAV heating components have relied on natural gas, which positions them as less sustainable compared to some alternatives. Electrifying these systems offers a pathway to reduce carbon footprint, although the overall efficiency will depend on factors like building size and design.
2. Central Plant Rooms: Boiler/Chiller Systems
Boiler/chiller systems are another frequently encountered option, particularly in larger buildings. You’ll typically discover boiler/chiller systems housed within central plant rooms in large commercial and residential buildings. These systems are hydronic, utilizing water as the heat transfer medium instead of forced air. Water is circulated through a network of pipes to air handlers throughout the building, where it either absorbs or releases heat to provide heating or cooling.
Compared to VAV systems, boiler/chiller systems generally offer enhanced energy efficiency. A key advantage is their ability to create multiple mechanical zones, allowing for simultaneous heating and cooling in different areas of a building, controlled by separate thermostats.
While more efficient, boiler/chiller systems usually involve a higher initial investment. Furthermore, many of these systems still rely on natural gas for boiler operation, contributing to carbon emissions.
3. Decentralized Locations: Variant Refrigerant Flow (VRF) Systems
VRF systems offer a more flexible approach to mechanical systems, allowing for more decentralized placement. Variant Refrigerant Flow (VRF) systems can be found in a wider range of locations, from plant rooms to individual floors or zones within both large commercial and smaller residential buildings. These systems use refrigerant circulating through pipes for both heating and cooling, enhancing efficiency compared to forced air systems. While ductwork is still needed for fresh air intake, it’s considerably smaller than in VAV systems, reducing fan energy requirements.
VRF systems are adaptable to diverse applications, from large-scale commercial complexes to smaller residential projects. Their compact ductwork and heating/cooling capabilities make them particularly well-suited for adaptive reuse projects and historic renovations. For instance, the Market One project in Des Moines utilized a VRF system to meet the requirements of federal historic tax credits.
While VRF systems tend to have a higher initial cost than VAV and boiler/chiller systems, their superior energy efficiency can yield a significant return on investment through reduced energy bills. Importantly, VRF systems often operate without relying on natural gas or other fossil fuels, making them a more sustainable choice.
types of mechanical systems3
Alt text: VRF system installation at Market One building, showcasing adaptable mechanical solution for historic renovation projects.
4. Exterior Building Perimeter: Air-Source Heat Pumps
Air-source heat pumps are often located on the exterior of buildings, providing localized heating and cooling. You can typically find air-source heat pumps placed outside buildings, often on walls or ground-level pads, serving specific zones or areas. A heat pump functions by transferring heat from one location to another using a small amount of energy. In heating mode, it extracts heat from the outside air and moves it indoors. This process is reversible for cooling during warmer months.
Heat pumps stand out as some of the most energy-efficient systems because they transfer heat rather than generating it through fuel combustion.
However, air-source heat pumps generally have a higher initial cost and might not suit all budgets. Their performance is also climate-dependent, working most effectively in temperate regions. In areas with significant seasonal temperature swings, supplemental heating systems or ground-source heat pumps might be necessary.
5. Underground or Ground Level: Ground-Source Heat Pumps
Ground-source heat pumps leverage the earth’s stable temperature, requiring specific site conditions for installation. Ground-source heat pumps are found with their major components either underground or at ground level adjacent to buildings, utilizing geothermal energy. These systems capitalize on the relatively consistent temperature of the earth to provide heating and cooling throughout the year.
Among the five systems discussed, ground-source heat pumps are recognized for their exceptional efficiency and sustainability. However, they typically require more extensive on-site installation, which increases the initial project cost. Geothermal energy projects are often subject to regulations by environmental agencies, necessitating a review of local restrictions before pursuing this option.
Factors Influencing Mechanical System Location and Efficiency
Generally, mechanical systems with higher initial costs are associated with lower life cycle costs and offer better long-term returns. While air-source and ground-source heat pumps lead in efficiency and sustainability, their optimal application depends on the building’s specific characteristics and usage. The location of these systems can also be influenced by building design and available space.
For example, heat pump systems excel in buildings with moderate temperature fluctuations. However, buildings like laboratories or data centers that demand consistent year-round cooling might pose challenges. In such cases, a heat pump system would necessitate a significantly larger ground loop or outdoor unit field, driving up initial expenses. A VRF system might prove to be a more practical choice when considering both life cycle and operational costs in these scenarios.
Occupancy patterns and thermal comfort requirements also play a crucial role in system selection and location. Some highly energy-efficient systems might struggle to maintain adequate cooling during periods of high occupancy.
Churches, for example, experience significant variations in occupancy. While Sundays see large gatherings, the building is used by fewer people during the week.
In situations with fluctuating occupancy, combined systems can offer an effective solution. A ground-source heat pump could serve as the primary system during low-occupancy periods, with a supplementary VAV unit activated to handle peak cooling demands in spaces like the sanctuary.
Ultimately, energy efficiency is just one of several factors to weigh when selecting a mechanical system and determining its optimal location. Consulting with an architect and mechanical engineer is essential to evaluate all relevant factors and identify the most cost-effective and appropriately located option for your specific building needs.
types of mechanical systems2
Alt text: Combined mechanical systems in a church building, illustrating solutions for buildings with variable occupancy needs.
Strategic Investments Beyond Mechanical Systems
Choosing a mechanical system is a pivotal decision in any building project. This choice has long-lasting implications for your operational budget and environmental footprint. While efficient systems like heat pumps and VRF systems might entail higher initial costs, the long-term energy savings often justify the investment. Careful consideration of system location can also optimize performance and accessibility for maintenance.
The efficiency of these systems is influenced by factors like building size, function, and local climate. Your architect and engineer can provide thorough analysis of these factors and detailed life cycle cost projections.
Remember, the mechanical system is one of many potential investments in a building project. To explore further options, you can learn about seven investments that improve building performance.
