For fans of classic television comedy, the cry of “Car 54, Where Are You?” still rings with laughter. This iconic show, a true gem from the golden age of TV, delivered seasons of comedic brilliance. While full series DVD releases remain elusive, glimpses into its genius, like the episodes featured on a vintage VHS tape, remind us of its enduring appeal. This review revisits two such episodes, highlighting why “Car 54, Where Are You?” continues to be celebrated as a comedy classic.
One episode, a personal favorite titled “The Taming of Lucille,” showcases the show’s signature blend of slapstick and relatable domestic humor. Gunther Toody, portrayed hilariously by Joe E. Ross, finds himself inspired to assert dominance at home after watching “The Taming of the Shrew” and witnessing his cousin’s seemingly controlled marriage. Alongside his ever-patient partner Francis Muldoon, played by Fred Gwynne, Toody’s attempts to “tame” his wife Lucille, brought to life by the comedic talents of Beatrice Pons, unfold in riotous and ultimately endearing ways. Ross and Pons, familiar to audiences from their roles in “You’ll Never Get Rich,” bring their established chemistry to these beloved characters.
Another memorable episode sees Toody’s comedic talents unexpectedly thrust into the spotlight on the “Jack Paar Show.” When a fellow officer’s stand-up routine falters due to stage fright, Toody steps in to save the day, becoming an instant hit with the audience and host Hugh Downs. This episode, while perhaps not as overtly comedic as “The Taming of Lucille,” perfectly captures the show’s charm and ability to find humor in everyday situations and the personalities of its characters. It’s a testament to the show’s writers and performers that even in a slightly less farcical scenario, the laughs are plentiful.
These two episodes alone offer a delightful 50-minute glimpse into the world of “Car 54, Where Are You?”. They are a reminder of the show’s comedic genius and leave viewers longing for a complete series release. For anyone seeking classic television laughs, discovering or revisiting “Car 54, Where Are You?” is a worthwhile endeavor.
