Modern Christianity’s global presence is undeniable. In 2022, over 30% of the world’s population identified as Christian, a testament to its far-reaching influence. This vastness can sometimes obscure the humble beginnings of this faith. To truly understand Christianity, we must journey back to its origins and explore the pivotal locations that shaped its formative years. Where Did Christianity Originate From, and how did the environments of its birth influence its core tenets and evolving practices? Let’s embark on this historical exploration.
The Genesis of Christianity: Tracing Back to its Source
Christianity, at its heart, is inextricably linked to Jesus Christ. Therefore, our quest to understand where Christianity originated from naturally begins with examining Jesus’s own origins. Jesus hailed from Nazareth, a small, seemingly insignificant village nestled in the Galilee region of northern Palestine. To grasp the nascent stages of Christianity, we must first understand the context of 1st-century Galilee, the geographical and societal landscape that cradled Jesus and his initial followers.
The Galilee of the 1st century was geographically divided into Lower and Upper Galilee. Nazareth and the Sea of Galilee, the very waters where Jesus’s disciples, many of whom were fishermen, plied their trade and were called to follow him, were situated in Lower Galilee, the southern part of the region. Thus, when investigating Christianity’s place of origin, Lower Galilee becomes our primary focus.
View of Sea of Galilee, Israel, showcasing the serene waters and surrounding hills, reflecting the geographical context of early Christianity.
Lower Galilee was characterized by two principal urban centers: Sepphoris and Tiberius. Tiberius graced the western shores of the Sea of Galilee, while Sepphoris was positioned inland, a mere 3.5 miles from Nazareth. Historically significant, Sepphoris had faced destruction at the hands of Roman forces around 4 BCE in response to a Jewish revolt, coinciding with the approximate time of Jesus’s birth. During Jesus’s lifetime, Sepphoris was likely undergoing a period of reconstruction and rebuilding.
Sakari Häkkinen, in his scholarly work, notes that agriculture was the dominant occupation in Lower Galilee, with a smaller segment engaged in fishing around the Sea of Galilee. However, prosperity was not widespread. A stark reality of the time was that approximately 90% of the population existed at a subsistence level, constantly striving to secure their basic needs.
John Kloppenborg aptly describes the precariousness of life for the average Galilean in the 1st century:
One bad harvest or one serious misfortune might mean the loss of everything, since the new patronal class, already viewed with distrust, could not be depended upon for help.
This paints a picture of a society lacking a robust social safety net, where vulnerability to economic hardship was a constant threat for the majority.
The Galilean Milieu: Shaping Jesus’s Teachings
The Gospels identify Jesus as a carpenter. John Dominic Crossan posits that this profession placed Jesus within the artisan class, living close to the subsistence line, perpetually vulnerable to economic downturns. This Galilean backdrop and his socioeconomic standing profoundly influenced Jesus’s teachings, imbuing them with a relatable context for his audience.
Consider Jesus’s parables. Parables such as the Sower, the Growing Seed, the Mustard Seed, and the Tares are rich with agricultural imagery. These parables resonated deeply with his primarily agrarian Galilean audience, who were intimately familiar with the cycles of sowing, reaping, and the challenges of farming. His metaphors drew from their daily lives, making his spiritual lessons tangible and accessible.
Several other parables directly address themes of poverty and economic hardship. The Parable of the Workers in the Vineyard, for instance, highlights the potential injustices within the economic system, depicting a vineyard owner who pays all laborers the same wage, regardless of their hours worked. This parable could have resonated with the Galilean laborers who often faced unfair labor practices.
Debt was an ever-present burden for the impoverished in Galilee. The Parable of the Unforgiving Servant poignantly illustrates this, narrating the story of a servant whose substantial debt is forgiven, yet he refuses to extend the same forgiveness to a fellow debtor. The lesson of mercy and compassion would have resonated powerfully with those struggling under the weight of debt.
Furthermore, Jesus’s teachings in Matthew 6:25-30 directly address the anxieties of subsistence living:
“Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat or what you will drink, or about your body, what you will wear. Is not life more than food and the body more than clothing? Look at the birds of the air: they neither sow nor reap nor gather into barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not of more value than they? And which of you by worrying can add a single hour to your span of life? And why do you worry about clothing? Consider the lilies of the field, how they grow; they neither toil nor spin, yet I tell you, even Solomon in all his glory was not clothed like one of these. But if God so clothes the grass of the field, which is alive today and tomorrow is thrown into the oven, will he not much more clothe you—you of little faith?”
For a subsistence farmer in Galilee, constantly facing the threat of losing everything, these words carried a radical message of hope and trust in divine providence. It was a profound reassurance against the backdrop of their precarious existence, far more impactful than it might seem to a modern, middle-class individual.
Jesus’s origins in 1st-century Galilee were not merely a matter of geography; his Galilean context, encompassing its socioeconomic realities, profoundly shaped his worldview and the very essence of his teachings.
NOW AVAILABLE!
Paul and Jesus: The Great Divide™
Explore the complex relationship between Paul and Jesus in this thought-provoking course. Did they share the same religion, or are they co-founders of Christianity?
Promotional banner for the online course "Paul and Jesus: The Great Divide™" by Bart Ehrman, featuring an image of Bart Ehrman and course title.The Religious Tapestry of 1st-Century Galilee
The dominant religious environment of 1st-century Galilee was undoubtedly Judaism. The majority of Galileans were Jewish, and their religious life was rooted in the traditions and practices of Judaism of that era. Jerusalem, located in Judea, was the central hub of Jewish religious life, housing the Temple, the focal point for major Jewish festivals and sacrificial rituals. While pilgrimage to Jerusalem, particularly for Passover, was a significant aspect of Jewish practice, as exemplified by Jesus’s own journeys, religious life was vibrant within Galilee itself.
Synagogues served as the cornerstone of religious life outside of Jerusalem. The term “synagogue” originates from the Greek word meaning “a place of assembly.” Archaeological discoveries have substantiated the role of synagogues as community centers for discourse and learning. They were public institutions with both religious and political dimensions, playing a significant role in the social fabric of Galilean towns and villages.
Remarkably, over 50 ancient synagogue sites dating back to the early 1st century CE and later have been unearthed in Galilee, highlighting the pervasiveness of synagogues in the region.
It is therefore not surprising that the Gospels frequently depict Jesus preaching in synagogues. In town after town, including his own Nazareth, the Gospels record Jesus entering the synagogue and teaching (Mark 1:21, Matthew 4:23). Synagogues offered Jesus a readily available audience, a place where people naturally congregated, allowing him to disseminate his teachings effectively within the existing religious framework of Galilean society.
Having established the geographical, economic, social, and religious context of 1st-century Galilee, we now turn our attention to the subsequent spread of Christianity beyond Palestine, specifically to Asia Minor, and explore how this new setting further shaped its development.
Did You Know?
Speculation exists that Jesus, during his youth as a carpenter, might have found employment in Sepphoris during its reconstruction phase. Given the prevalence of Greek in Galilean urban centers like Sepphoris and Tiberius, some scholars have also proposed that Jesus might have possessed a working knowledge of Greek. However, Bart Ehrman challenges this notion, arguing that rural dwellers like the inhabitants of Nazareth had limited mobility and interaction with broader urban centers. Furthermore, the New Testament makes no direct mention of Sepphoris. While the possibility of Jesus visiting Sepphoris cannot be entirely dismissed, there is no concrete evidence to support the claim that he did, or that he was fluent in Greek.
From Galilee to Asia Minor: The Expanding Horizon of Christianity
While Galilee in Palestine served as the initial place where Christianity originated, the religion’s trajectory soon extended beyond its birthplace, largely due to the efforts of Paul and other missionaries. Asia Minor became a crucial region in this expansion, witnessing the early development and transformation of Christianity. To understand this next phase, we must examine 1st-century Asia Minor and its influence on shaping the evolving Christian faith, with a particular focus on the Apostle Paul’s role.
Paul, a figure of immense significance in early Christianity, hailed from Tarsus, a city in Cilicia, within the Roman province of Asia Minor. Following his conversion experience, Paul dedicated his life to spreading the message of Jesus, establishing Christian communities in numerous cities across Asia Minor, including Ephesus, Galatia, Laodicea, and Pergamum, before venturing into Greece. Given Paul’s Asian Minor origins and his extensive missionary work in the region, it is crucial to consider the geographical and cultural context of Asia Minor.
The map below illustrates the geographical locations of these key areas, including Paul’s missionary journeys.
Map showing Israel, Galatia, and Asia Minor, highlighting the geographical scope of early Christian expansion and Paul's missionary routes.
Asia Minor, a peninsula bridging Asia and Europe, presented a stark contrast to rural Galilee. Unlike the predominantly rural Galilee, Asia Minor was characterized by its urban centers and a thriving cosmopolitan culture. Numerous large cities dotted the landscape, making it a hub of commerce, intellectual exchange, and cultural diversity.
Like Palestine, Asia Minor had experienced the influence of Alexander the Great and became part of his Hellenistic empire, later falling under Roman rule. However, Asia Minor had deeply absorbed Greek culture and language. Greek was the lingua franca, the primary language spoken by most inhabitants, including Paul himself. Greek philosophy, encompassing the teachings of Plato, Aristotle, and the Stoics, permeated the intellectual landscape, and temples dedicated to Greek and Roman deities were prominent features of the urban environment.
Greco-Roman Influences: Shaping Paul’s Theology
Despite his strong Jewish identity, Paul was immersed in Greco-Roman culture from birth. This upbringing did not diminish his Jewishness but rather enriched his perspective, adding layers of understanding absent in the teachings of Jesus and his Galilean disciples. Paul’s background and thought processes were distinctly different from those rooted solely in the Galilean context.
Emily Wilson, a classicist, highlights the profound influence of Stoic philosophy on Paul’s thinking. She notes that Paul adopted Stoic concepts such as “indifferent things,” the importance of inner control, the ideal of freedom from passions, and the seemingly paradoxical notion of “freedom through slavery.”
Scholarly debate continues regarding the extent to which Paul consciously borrowed from Greek philosophy. It is plausible that these concepts were so deeply ingrained in the cultural fabric of Asia Minor that they permeated his thinking organically, alongside his Pharisaic Judaism. Regardless of the mechanism, this synthesis of Jewish and Greco-Roman thought marked a significant departure from the original teachings of Jesus.
Paul’s use of the term “spirit” (Greek: pneuma) provides a compelling example. Troels Engberg-Pedersen points out that in contemporary understanding, “spirit” or “spiritual” denotes something immaterial and intangible. However, Paul’s conception of “spirit” appears to be different.
Engberg-Pedersen suggests that Paul viewed “spirit” as a physical entity, albeit of a highly refined nature, capable of interacting with the physical world. This understanding aligns closely with Stoic philosophical concepts, indicating either direct engagement with Stoic texts or the pervasive influence of Stoic thought in Asia Minor during Paul’s time. Both possibilities are highly plausible.
It is crucial to reiterate that these Greco-Roman influences did not negate Paul’s Jewish identity. His writings are replete with references to the Hebrew Bible, and his interpretation of Christ’s significance is deeply rooted in his exegesis of Hebrew Scriptures. Paul proudly affirmed his Jewish heritage and his adherence to Jewish law, as expressed in Philippians 3:6.
If anyone else has reason to be confident in the flesh, I have more: circumcised on the eighth day, a member of the people of Israel, of the tribe of Benjamin, a Hebrew born of Hebrews; as to the law, a Pharisee; as to zeal, a persecutor of the church; as to righteousness under the law, blameless.
However, the integration of Greek philosophical thought into his Jewish faith resulted in a distinct theological framework that differed in significant ways from the teachings circulating within the Jerusalem Church. This divergence may shed light on the conflicts Paul experienced with Peter and James in Antioch, Syria, as recounted in Galatians 2:11-13.
Paul’s teachings also reflect his urban Greco-Roman environment through the use of relatable imagery. In 2 Corinthians 10:3-4, Paul employs the metaphor of warfare:
Indeed, we live as humans but do not wage war according to human standards, for the weapons of our warfare are not merely human, but they have divine power to destroy strongholds.
The Roman Empire in the 1st century was perpetually engaged in warfare, either expanding its territories or defending its borders. References to weapons and warfare would have resonated strongly with Paul’s audience in Asia Minor, who were accustomed to the visible presence of Roman soldiers. In contrast, Galilee lacked a significant Roman military presence.
Furthermore, Paul utilizes athletic imagery, drawing from the Isthmian Games, a prominent Olympic-style competition held in Corinth. In his first letter to the Corinthian community, Paul employs athletic metaphors to illustrate the Christian life:
Do you not know that in a race the runners all compete, but only one receives the prize? Run in such a way that you may win it. Athletes exercise self-control in all things; they do it to receive a perishable wreath, but we an imperishable one. So I do not run aimlessly, nor do I box as though beating the air…1 Corinthians 9:24–26
References to running races, boxing, and striving for victory in athletic contests served as powerful metaphors for living a life pleasing to God and seeking eternal rewards. These Greco-Roman athletic images were congruent with Paul’s cultural background and that of his audience in Asia Minor.
Conclusion: Galilee and Asia Minor – Two Pillars of Christian Origins
Understanding the history of ideas necessitates acknowledging the profound influence of geographical and cultural contexts. These settings shape our thinking and perspectives in fundamental ways.
While the basic narrative of Christian origins is widely known, the crucial role of the geographical locations where it emerged, developed, and spread is often overlooked. So, where did Christianity originate from? The answer, in its initial stages, is Galilee.
Galilee, the birthplace and home of Jesus and his first disciples, was a region of striking natural beauty juxtaposed with widespread poverty. Jesus and his followers likely came from humble backgrounds, possibly experiencing economic insecurity and hardship. This Galilean reality indelibly shaped Jesus’s teachings.
His parables and pronouncements frequently addressed the lives of agricultural laborers, the ethical dilemmas of landowners and workers, and the pervasive anxieties of the poor. Coupled with the social and religious influence of synagogues, this Galilean context contributed to Jesus’s unique interpretation of 1st-century Judaism.
Paul, while deeply committed to his Jewish faith, was also a product of Asia Minor, a Greek-speaking Roman province where he was born, raised, and conducted much of his missionary work. Paul, whether consciously or unconsciously, synthesized faith in the God of Israel with elements of Stoic philosophy, giving rise to a new religious expression that flourished in Asia Minor and beyond.
Therefore, while the seeds of Christianity were sown in Galilee, Asia Minor can be considered the region where Christianity began to take root and grow as a distinct and expanding movement. Both Galilee and Asia Minor, with their unique geographical, cultural, and socioeconomic landscapes, played indispensable roles in shaping the origins and early development of Christianity.
NOW AVAILABLE:
Jesus the Secret Messiah™: Revealing the Mysteries of the Gospel of Mark
Unlock the enigmatic Gospel of Mark in this insightful course. Was Mark an eyewitness to Jesus’s life, or was his Gospel a product of later interpretations?
Promotional banner for the online course "Jesus the Secret Messiah™" by Bart Ehrman, featuring an image of Bart Ehrman and course title.